Short answer: the quality report is your proof that the fabric meets spec

Fabric inspection is the checking of finished cloth before delivery — hunting for defects and deviations from the agreed spec. It is not just "a look": it is a set of methods that turns what the inspector sees into scores, quantities and records a buyer can use to accept or negotiate with the mill.

Why fabric inspection matters

Good inspection is not done only before packing — it happens across the whole production chain, because every step can release different defects.

  • Pre-dyeing — check the greige fabric: weaving defects, yarn defects, sizing, weight GSM, width, shade
  • In-process — monitor during dyeing and finishing: colour consistency, shrinkage, chemical residues
  • Final — inspect the last roll before packing: visual check, GSM, width, length, shade and fastness testing

Inspecting at all three layers prevents two expensive problems: receiving defective cloth without knowing, and shipping defective cloth that comes back later.

4-Point System: the international defect-scoring method

The 4-Point is the defect-scoring method used widely in international trade (applied together with visual inspection per ASTM D5430). The inspector measures each defect found and converts it to a score:

  • up to 7.5 cm (3 in) → 1 point
  • 7.5–15 cm → 2 points
  • 15–23 cm → 3 points
  • more than 23 cm → 4 points

Two extra rules people often miss:

  • a hole or missing spot scores 2 points if it is 2.5 cm (1 in) or smaller, and 4 points if larger
  • a continuous defect (e.g. a full-width shade bar) scores 4 points per yard (or metre) it affects, and no yard (or metre) scores more than 4 points in total, however many defects it contains

Scores from every yard (or metre) are converted to a score per 100 square yards (or 100 square metres, depending on the agreed contract), and buyer and mill agree the pass/fail line in advance (e.g. no more than 60 points per 100 square yards).

The point of the 4-Point System is that it ends the "bad or not bad?" argument — once both sides count the same way, the inspection report alone can decide.

The 10-Point System: another defect-scoring method

The 10-Point System is the other widely used defect-scoring method in international fabric trade — Cotton Incorporated lists the 4-Point and 10-Point systems as the two most common used worldwide. Instead of scoring 1/2/3/4 by defect length, it uses 1, 3, 5 or 10 points, so a long defect or a defect running the full width of the fabric weighs far more in the total score — a full-width defect scores the maximum 10 points. A common acceptance rule is that the total points for a roll should not exceed the number of yards (or metres) inspected; the exact limit is agreed between buyer and mill.

BCI (Boonchuay Industrial) uses the 10-point system in its quality reporting: every lot of finished fabric passes the three-layer inspection before packing and is documented in a 10-point system quality report — cloth is packed for delivery only after the report meets the agreed standard.

Which defects are serious, which are minor?

Common criteria for "serious":

  • shade (shade bar): serious when it exceeds the agreed tolerance
  • a hole or missing spot: serious in every case
  • a continuous full-width defect (shade bar): serious

In practice: agree the major/minor defect list and tolerances up front — it saves arguments later.

What is on a fabric inspection report?

A standard report includes:

  • fabric ID, lot number, inspection date
  • yards/metres inspected
  • score summary (4-Point or 10-Point, as agreed)
  • defect types and locations (so they can be re-checked or cut out)
  • test results (if in the spec)
  • pass/fail conclusion
  • inspector's signature

The report is the evidence of the delivery — if the buyer finds a problem later, this document is the first piece of evidence.

How is the inspection done?

  • Light: under a standard light box (e.g. D65 or TL-84, as agreed) — never judge shade under mixed office lighting
  • Table: a flat, well-lit table; the cloth moves past the inspector at a constant speed
  • Record: mark the position of every defect and log it in the inspection sheet
  • Score: convert to points by the agreed method

What happens when cloth fails inspection?

Common options:

  • re-inspection after the mill has cut out the defects
  • discount: accept with a reduction based on the defect score
  • return or rework: for critical defects such as a full-width shade bar or holes
  • re-test: for failed test items, e.g. fastness below the agreed grade

Most important: agree in advance who decides and how — before production, not after the problem.

Why use a third-party fabric inspector?

Buyers who do not inspect in-house (or have no lab) can use a third-party inspection service — an independent inspector checks at the mill or at the buyer's factory and issues a report both sides accept.

Boonchuay Industrial (BCI)

BCI (Boonchuay Industrial), in Nakhon Pathom, has its own lab and a three-layer inspection process:

  1. Pre-dyeing — greige fabric inspected before it enters the dye house
  2. In-process — checked during dyeing and finishing
  3. Final inspection — before packing

BCI also runs its own colour-fastness testing — light, water, perspiration and washing (for example per ISO 105-C06 or AATCC 61), plus chlorine, rubbing, tensile and tear, colour bleeding and shrinkage — against ISO, JIS, AATCC or Daimaru, as the buyer specifies. Test results are issued alongside the 10-point system quality report for every lot.

For more on BCI's testing, read the article fabric quality testing, and see BCI's lab and standards at BCI lab & standards.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between 4-Point and 10-Point?

A: Both are defect-scoring methods agreed between buyer and mill — 4-Point scores 1–4 points by defect length, while 10-Point scores 1, 3, 5 or 10, so long or full-width defects weigh far more. BCI issues a 10-point system quality report for every lot.

Q: What score passes?

A: There is no fixed standard — buyer and mill agree (a commonly seen threshold, for example, is under 60 points per 100 square yards).

Q: Does every defect score 4 points?

A: No — points follow the length table; a hole of 2.5 cm or less scores 2 points, and no yard scores more than 4 points in total.

Q: Should the report include test results?

A: Yes, if the spec sets performance requirements (fastness, shrinkage, etc.) — with the standard used (ISO, AATCC, JIS) and the result.

Q: Can cloth be shipped without a report?

A: Not recommended — the report is the evidence of acceptance and the main tool for resolving disputes.

Contact for inspection and dyeing

If you are looking for a dyeing mill with its own lab, three-layer inspection and a 10-Point quality report — contact Boonchuay Industrial (BCI) to discuss fabric dyeing, finished cloth and uniform fabrics.

References